Quick Answer: What Is the Best Beginner Jellycat?

For the absolute safest, most loved first pick: the Bashful Bunny in Medium size. It’s the icon of the brand, the one that started millions of collections. It’s soft, simple, comes in dozens of colors, and fits perfectly in your hand or on a shelf. Second runner-up: the Smudge Elephant—unbelievably floppy, calming to hold, and ideal for both kids and adults who want a squishy friend to carry around.

But that’s just the start. The “best” beginner Jellycat really depends on whether you want something classic, silly, or extra cozy. So let’s break it down.

Why Jellycats Are Perfect for First-Time Buyers

Jellycat has been around since 1999, but it’s exploded recently thanks to TikTok unboxings, collector hauls, and the rise of “cozy aesthetic” living. People aren’t just buying stuffed animals anymore—they’re buying little personalities that spark joy, nostalgia, and comfort.

Here’s why they make such a strong first impression:

• Unreal softness. The fabrics (especially the “Bashful” fur and “Smudge” plush) are engineered to be touched. You’ll find yourself petting your Jellycat while watching TV, without even realizing it.

• Weight and feel. Jellycats are weighted just enough to feel substantial, but not heavy. It’s that “just right” balance that makes them perfect for cuddling, displaying, or bringing on a trip.

• Silly or sweet? There’s a Jellycat for every mood. Want a realistic-looking lobster? They have it. Want a smiling avocado? You got it. Prefer a classic teddy? The Bashful Bear is waiting.

• Collectible value. While Jellycats are made to be loved, many styles become rare or retired, creating a secondary market. Your first Jellycat could be the beginning of a meaningful collection.

Tip: If you’re still unsure, browse the Best Sellers & Most Loved Soft Toys on the official Jellycat site to see what tens of thousands of others chose first. It’s a great way to spot patterns.

What to Look for in a First Jellycat

Before you click “add to cart,” there are a few things to consider. Think of this as your beginner checklist.

Size: Small, Medium, or Large?

Jellycats come in a wide size range, from tiny keychain plush (around 12 cm) to giant “My” versions that are almost pillow-sized.

For your first Jellycat, Medium is the sweet spot. It’s big enough to feel like a real friend, but small enough to take with you.

Texture: Bashful vs. Smudge vs. Amuseable

Each Jellycat line has a distinct feel:

• Bashful – silky, dense fur; very huggable. The fur can slightly flatten with love, but it always bounces back.

• Smudge – ultra-floppy, with a slightly longer, softer plush. These feel like they’re melting in your arms. Best for sensory comfort.

• Amuseable – these are the food and object characters (toast, avocado, coffee). They have a mix of smooth, printed fabrics and soft plush. More playful, less traditional snuggly.

Recommendation: For a first Jellycat, if you prioritize cuddliness, go Smudge. If you want the iconic Jellycat look, go Bashful. If you want a conversation starter, go Amuseable.

Character: Classic or Quirky?

Classic characters (bunnies, bears, puppies) are timeless and easy to love. Quirky characters (the Amuseable series) are perfect if you want something unique and often become viral on Pinterest and TikTok. The Beginner’s Guide to Jellycats suggests starting with a character that reflects your personality—whether that’s a sensible owl, a goofy pancake, or a shy fox.

Best Beginner Jellycats: Our Top Picks

Now let’s get into the good stuff. Here are my personal recommendations for first-time buyers, based on popularity, comfort, and overall “beginner-friendliness.”

1. Bashful Bunny (Medium) – The Ultimate Starter

• Why it’s perfect: It’s the face of Jellycat. Soft, sweet, and available in over 30 colors. The ears are long and floppy—perfect for holding.

• Best for: Anyone who wants a “safe” first choice. Also great for gifting.

• Sensory note: The fur is dense and velvety. Some people find it calming to stroke.

2. Smudge Elephant (Medium) – The Cuddle Champion

• Why it’s perfect: This is the floppiest, most relaxed Jellycat. It collapses into your hands. The trunk, ears, and legs all hang loosely.

• Best for: People who want a stress-relief plush or a travel buddy.

• Sensory note: The longer fur feels different from Bashful—more like a well-loved blanket.

3. Amuseable Toast

• Why it’s perfect: It’s funny, cute, and weird. Plus it has little legs and a happy face. This is the Jellycat that goes viral on Pinterest.

• Best for: Aesthetic lovers, people who want a desk friend, or anyone who appreciates humor in their plush.

• Sensory note: The bread part is smooth printed fabric, the “butter” is soft plush. A nice mix.

4. Bashful Dragon

• Why it’s perfect: Dragons are trending in plush culture, and this one has soft horns, wings, and a stitched smile. It’s a bit more unique than the bunny but still classic.

• Best for: Fantasy lovers or those who want something slightly edgy but still cuddly.

5. Smudge Fox

• Why it’s perfect: Foxes are universally adored, and the Smudge Fox is extra floppy. The red-and-white colorway looks great on any shelf.

• Best for: Nature lovers, or as a gift for a friend who adores foxes.

6. Amuseable Avocado

• Why it’s perfect: Another viral hit. It’s a smiling avocado with a big pit. Impossible to look at without smiling.

• Best for: Millennials, kitchen decor, or ironic cute decor.

Size Matters: Choosing the Right Size for Your First Jellycat

I already touched on size, but let’s go deeper. One common mistake first-time buyers make is ordering a size that feels awkward once it arrives.

Tiny (12–18 cm) – Great for attaching to bags or keys, but too small for cuddling. These are more of an accessory.

Medium (31 cm) – The standard. Matches the size of a small throw pillow. Fits in a tote bag. Perfect for one-armed hugs.

Large (36–50 cm) – These are big. The Large Bashful Bunny is about 46 cm tall. Wonderful for hugging in bed, but takes up a lot of shelf space.

My (huge, 69–76 cm) – These are close to life-size for some animals. The “My” range (My Bashful Bunny, My Bashful Puppy) is for serious collectors. Not recommended for beginners unless you have a lot of space—and cash.

Recommendation: Start with Medium. You can always add a larger or smaller one later. The Medium size gives you the full Jellycat experience without commitment to a giant plush.

Pros and Cons of Starting a Jellycat Collection

Let’s be honest—buying your first Jellycat is rarely just one. It’s the start of something. Here’s a balanced look at the upsides and downsides.

Pros

• Instant comfort. There’s research around “transitional objects” and how soft plush can reduce anxiety. Jellycats excel at this.

• Beautiful design. They look great on a bed, shelf, or couch. Many people style them in photos for Instagram and Pinterest.

• Gift appeal. A Jellycat is a nearly universal gift—safe for kids, loved by adults, and always appreciated.

• Collector community. The Jellycat fandom online is huge, friendly, and active. You’ll find endless inspiration.

• Potential value. Some retired Jellycats sell for multiples of their original price. While we don’t encourage buying for profit, it’s nice to know your plush might hold value.

Cons

• Addiction is real. Many collectors admit to spending more than planned. It’s easy to fall into the “just one more” trap.

• Price. Jellycats aren’t cheap. Medium Bashfuls are around $35–$45 USD. Larger ones can be $60+. It adds up.

• Care required. Most Jellycats are surface-wash only. The fur can mat if not handled gently. They’re not dirt-proof.

• Retirement stress. When Jellycat discontinues a design, some people panic-buy. That can create FOMO.

Why Jellycats Are Going Viral Right Now

It’s not just you—Jellycats are everywhere. TikTok videos with the hashtag #jellycat have over 3 billion views. On Pinterest, “Jellycat aesthetic” boards are packed with cozy room decor and plushie flat lays.

What’s driving this?

• Comfort culture. After the pandemic, people started seeking small, affordable luxuries that bring joy. A $35 Jellycat is cheaper than a spa day and lasts forever.

• Sensory trends. ASMR videos of Jellycat fur being stroked, or of the weight of a Smudge plush being lifted, are hugely popular.

• “Cozy gaming” crossover. The same people who love Animal Crossing and Stardew Valley also love Jellycats. They fit the same wholesome, low-stress vibe.

• Aesthetic gifting. Gifting a Jellycat wrapped in tissue paper, with a hand-written note, has become a TikTok trend. It’s the ultimate “thinking of you” item.

One of the best places to explore trending Jellycat styles is this enthusiast’s roundup on The Independent, which lists current favorites and new releases.

FAQ: Your First Jellycat Questions Answered

Are you ready to start your Jellycat journey?

If you’ve read this far, yes. The only real requirement is a willingness to fall in love with a plush toy. If you’re a parent looking for a first Jellycat for your child, also check out this guide on best Jellycat toys for newborns – though many of the same principles apply to adults.

Do Jellycats make good collector items?

Absolutely. Jellycat releases new designs seasonally and retires others. Some collectors focus on one character (like all Bashful Bunnies) or one theme (food, animals, seasonal). Others just buy whatever makes them happy. They’re not high-investment collectibles like limited-edition sneakers, but they do hold sentimental and sometimes resale value. The fun is in the hunt—and the display.

What would you recommend as a first Jellycat?

I’d say a Medium Bashful Bunny in a neutral color (beige, cream, gray) or a Medium Smudge Elephant. Both are universally loved, easy to find, and represent the best of Jellycat’s design philosophy. If you want something with more personality, go Amuseable Toast.

Where can I buy Jellycats?

Jellycats are available on the official website, but also at many retailers. Check out this detailed guide on stores that sell Jellycats – it covers online and local options.

How do I care for my Jellycat?

Most Jellycats can be surface cleaned with a damp cloth and mild soap. Avoid machine washing unless the tag specifically says it’s machine-washable (some of the “Bashful” range are). Always air dry. The fur may need gentle brushing with a soft brush if it mats.

Can I display Jellycats on my bed without them getting dirty?

Yes, but rotate them. If one stays on your bed full-time, it will get flat spots and dust. Many collectors keep a “bed buddy” and rotate others on shelves.

Are Jellycats safe for babies?

Yes, most are designed for all ages, but always check the tag. Some have small parts like plastic eyes (though most now have embroidered eyes). The guide to Jellycat toys for newborns has specifics.

Conclusion: Your First Step Into a Softer World

To be honest, buying your first Jellycat feels a little silly until you do it. Then it feels like you’ve unlocked a secret door to a gentler, cozier part of the world. There’s something about holding a perfectly soft, weighted creature with a tiny stitched smile that makes everything feel okay.

Your first Jellycat doesn’t have to be the rarest or the most expensive. It just has to be the one that speaks to you—maybe a bashful bunny, maybe a smiling piece of toast. Once you bring it home, you’ll understand why millions of people around the world have started their own collections.

And if you’re thinking about starting, let me tell you: my first nail art at home experience was similarly satisfying—it was a small, creative step into a new hobby that brought me joy. Starting a Jellycat collection feels exactly like that. You begin with one, then suddenly you’re scouting for retired styles, arranging them on shelves, and sending photos to friends.

So go ahead. Choose your first. Squeeze it. Name it. Let it sit on your desk or bed. You’ve earned this softness.

Which Jellycat will be your first?

Tags: beginner, jellycats, first-time, buyers, jellycat